Size Comparison: Vhagar vs. Smaug

Here's an analysis of the size comparison between Vhagar and Smaug, drawing on available sources.

The question is which dragon is larger, Vhagar or Smaug. Several sources provide insights into their respective sizes.

Vhagar, from House of the Dragon, is described as one of the largest dragons in Westeros history, second only to Balerion the Black Dread [4]. While precise measurements are not given in the source material, Vhagar's size is often compared to Balerion, who was so large he could cast a shadow over entire towns [4]. Estimates suggest Balerion could be around 453 feet long [4]. Vhagar, nearing Balerion's size, is therefore exceptionally large [4].

Smaug, from The Hobbit, presents a different challenge in terms of size assessment. The books don't provide exact measurements, but the movies offer visual representations [4]. In the films, Smaug is depicted as being around 427 feet long with a wingspan of approximately 230 feet [4].

Additional Considerations

Considering these details, Vhagar appears to be slightly larger than Smaug [4]. The source material suggests Vhagar was almost as large as Balerion, who was potentially larger than Smaug [4].

Based on the available information, Vhagar is likely the larger dragon, although the size difference may not be substantial [4].

Conclusion

It's important to note that the size comparisons can vary based on the source material used (books vs. movies/shows). Also, the exact size of dragons is often left to interpretation, making definitive comparisons challenging.